Its biota has evolved in the arid rain shadow of the Rocky
Mountains, average annual precipitation ranging from approximately 10
inches in the foothills of Colorado to 50 inches in eastern
Kansas. Rainfall levels determine the predominant historical
grassland types, with shortgrass prairie furthest west, mixed-grass
prairie through the center, and tallgrass prairie on the eastern edge
(Bryce et al. 1996, Chapman et al. 2001).
The four states
included in the present survey, Kansas, Nebraska, South Dakota, and
North Dakota, lie primarily in the drainage of the Missouri River, with
its major tributaries, the Kansas/Republican, the Platte, the James,
the Niobrara, and the Cheyenne. Southern Kansas drains south
into
the Arkansas River with its major tributaries the Cimarron and the
Neosho, and northern North Dakota drains north into the Red River, with
its tributaries the Sheyenne and the Souris/Assiniboine. See
Figure 1 below.
Our study area also encompasses many dense
regions of small wetlands and ponds. These include the Sandhill Lakes
and Rainwater Basins of Nebraska, the wetland pools of the McPherson
Valley in Kansas, and the extensive prairie pothole region of eastern
North Dakota and northeastern South Dakota (USGS 1996). The southern
edge of the prairie potholes is approximately the extent of the most
recent glacial maximum, the Wisconsian (Wayne 1985). The reduction in
the number and area of wetlands in this region is a historical trend,
primarily due to the encroachment of agriculture (USGS 1996). Prairie
pothole wetlands declined by over 60% from 1850 to 1980 and continue to
be reduced by about 1% yearly (Dahl 2014).
Figure 1.
The drainage systems of our four-state Great Plains study
area, showing sample sites.
The Great Plains Ecoregion is not famous for its aquatic
biodiversity. When Lewis and Clark sailed up the Missouri
River
in 1804, they enthused about the vastness of the prairie, the richness
of the ungulate fauna, and the diversity of the Native American
cultures they met on their journey. The freshwater gastropod
fauna garnered nary a mention.
Nor indeed did aquatic
biodiversity figure in the first wave of European Americans who
followed Lewis and Clark into the Great Plains and beyond, just passing
through. The town of Kansas, now Kansas City, was formed in
1838
as an important starting point for the Oregon and Santa Fe
trails. Omaha, Nebraska, was founded as Omaha City in 1854
and
became the starting point for the first transcontinental railroad line,
completed in 1869 (Berg, 2011).
With the railroads came a
second wave of European American settlement, which with the passage of
the Homestead Act in 1862 and the cessation of hostilities in 1865,
became a deluge (Wishart 2013). Thousands of migrant families
began to arrive carrying the agricultural methods of eastern U.S.
settlements, livestock, and crops to feed them, primarily corn (Hudson,
2011). The rapid expansion of farm
culture
throughout the Great Plains in the late nineteenth century, together
with the cyclic droughts and the economic hardships that followed, have
been well-documented (Wishart 2011).
Today the Great Plains
of North America are an agricultural-dominated landscape, crops
dependent upon rainfall and growing season (Hudson 2011).
Wheat
is the primary crop in the northern and drier parts of our four-state
study area, in the Dakotas and the western halves of Nebraska and
Kansas. Corn, primarily for livestock feed, dominates eastern
Nebraska and Kansas. The Nebraska Sand Hills are primarily
given
over to livestock grazing.
Kansas
- Of the four states covered in the present survey, the freshwater
gastropod fauna of The Jayhawker State is best known. The
first
surveys of freshwater gastropods in Kansas were completed as a part of
the Washburn Biologic Survey and published by R. Ellsworth Call (1885a,
1885b, 1886, 1887). Call listed collection localities for 25
species, although several have been synonymized in modern
times.
Based on the locations observed, six species appeared common, Helisoma trivolvis,
Helisoma anceps,
Physa gyrina,
Physa acuta,
Campeloma decisum,
and Lymnaea catascopium.
Hanna
(1909) provided range expansions for several of Call’s species,
although adding no new species to his list. He documented seventeen
species from Douglas County, in the vicinity of Lawrence, remarking as
he did that ancylids were absent from his survey. That same year, Baker
(1909) reported fresh records of four freshwater gastropods from
Kansas, including Lymnaea
humilis (listed as L.
obrussa) new to the state.
Dorothea
Franzen and A. Byron Leonard contributed a list of eight species from
Kingman County in the south-central part of the state in
1942.
Subsequent work added range expansions for nine mollusks and included
the first observations of Pleurocera
potosienis and P.
acuta for the Jayhawker State (Franzen 1944).
Leonard’s
(1959) “Handbook of Gastropods in Kansas” was a landmark contribution
to our understanding of the malacofauna of the Great Plains.
Working from collections at the University of Kansas, Leonard
documented 20 species of freshwater snails, giving figures, detailed
descriptions, range maps, ecological notes, and synonymy.
Since
Leonard’s work, Kansas has received some attention, including a study
on the habitat preferences of terrestrial and aquatic mollusks, which
noted Physa gyrina
(listed as Physa hawnii)
as the most abundant freshwater gastropod (Basch et al.
1961).
Branson (1963, 1969) updated distribution records and taxonomy, lumping
(for example) Physa
anatina with Physa
virgata.
Angelo and colleagues (2002) published a revision of the distribution
of the Kansas prosobranch snails in 2002, suggesting as they did that Amnicola limosa
might be extirpated.
Nebraska
- The earliest systematic collections of the freshwater gastropod fauna
of the Great Plains were made by Ferdinand Hayden in 1868, shortly
after Nebraska was granted statehood. Lists and locations of
the
freshwater snails collected by the Hayden Expedition were published by
Tryon (1868), Aughey (1877), and Walker (1906). Aughey listed
forty-nine species and estimated their rarity, while Tryon (1868)
reported five species from the Omaha area. Walker (1906) listed
locations for 18 species, expanding the distribution of some species
while adding ten species he considered new to the State. These combined
records make up the bulk of the species of freshwater gastropods
reported historically for The Cornhusker State.
More recent work in Nebraska includes Gugler (1969) and Freeman and
Perkins (1992, 1997). Gugler (1969) reported abundant Valvata tricarinata
in a western Nebraska lake, although historical sources indicated but a
single rare occurrence. Freeman and Perkins (1992, 1997) sampled the
Platte and Niobrara Rivers, providing vital river data on seven species.
Stephen
(2015) reviewed and evaluated all historical and recent records of
freshwater gastropods for the state of Nebraska, updating the taxonomy
to modern standards. Ultimately, he counted 31 valid species
documented for the Cornhusker State, 30 indigenous and one
non-indigenous. Based on the number of historical records,
the
four most common species in Nebraska are Physa gyrina, Physa acuta, Lymnaea elodes, and
Aplexa elongata.
South Dakota
– Most of the previous research on the freshwater gastropods of the
Mount Rushmore State has come from just four studies, those of Over
(1915, 1915a, 1928) and Henderson (1927). Over (1915a, 1915b) listed 35
species, each with counties of record, later (1928) adding seven
species. Henderson (1927) provided county range extensions for eleven
species on Over’s list.
Recent work on South Dakota freshwater gastropods includes the
distribution of the non-indigenous snail Melanoides tuberculata
within the U.S., including Fall River and some smaller streams in and
around Hot Springs, South Dakota (Anderson 2004). Evaluation of the
records, combining synonyms and omitting likely misidentifications,
indicate that 25 species were historically present within the State
(Stephen 2018). The historically common species (based on the number of
literature records) are Physa
gyrina, Helisoma
trivolvis, Lymnaea
elodes, and Lymnnaea
caperata.
North Dakota
– The freshwater gastropod fauna of North Dakota was very poorly
documented for the first 100 years of its statehood. Hayden
(1862) mentioned two species of Amnicola
at Fort Berthold along the Missouri River, now under Lake
Sakakawea. Physa
gouldii (subsequently synonymized under P. gyrina) was
described by Clench (1935) from the Mouse River.
Tuthill
and Laird (1963) surveyed the alkaline lakes and palustrine habitats of
North Dakota’s Missouri Coteau (hilly upland) region, identifying 11
species, Physa
and Gyraulus
identified to genus only. They were impressed by the range of
alkalinities tolerated by several of the species, Helisoma trivolvis,
Lymnaea elodes
and Physa
sp. observed at pH ranging from 6.23 to 8.7.
Alan
Cvancara began his comprehensive survey of the aquatic mollusks of
North Dakota with a (1974) review of the fossil records, following nine
years later with a thorough and important guide to the recent
fauna. His (1983) report included descriptions, distribution
maps, and ecological notes for twenty-two freshwater snail species, the
five most common being Ferrissia
rivularis, Gyraulus
parvus, Helisoma
trivolvis, Physa
gyrina, and Physa
integra (now Physa
acuta).
> Methods
The database analyzed here comprises 1,474 records:
574
collected personally and 900 collected by state natural resource
agencies. Of these 620 came from Kansas, 362 from Nebraska,
314
from South Dakota, and 178 from North Dakota.
Through
the 1970s and 1980s, the Kansas Biological Survey conducted a
comprehensive survey of the macroinvertebrate fauna inhabiting waters
across the state. Methods were entirely qualitative. Sample sites were
chosen to cover the full range of freshwater habitat types in the state
across all counties and ecoregions, from playas, ditches, and private
farm ponds to large rivers and reservoirs. Collections were made by
teams of biologists using a variety of tools, kick nets, and simple
visual surveys. The freshwater gastropod component of these extensive
collections was curated into the Museum of the University of Kansas.
We
visited the KU Museum on January 25 – 27, 2022, reviewing 642
freshwater gastropod lots collected from 1971 – 1981 from Kansas.
Subtracting unidentifiable and otherwise unqualified lots and expanding
mixed lots ultimately yielded 580 records. The remainder of our Kansas
records were from personal collections primarily by our collaborator,
Will K. Reeves.
BJS collected and compiled most of our
Nebraska and South Dakota records in connection with his dissertation
research (Stephen 2017, 2018). Additional records for Nebraska and
South Dakota were from personal collections by WKR and others.
Macrobenthic samples collected from the Rivers and Streams Program of
the Nebraska Game and Parks Commission using qualitative visual surveys
contributed 142 Nebraska records. All Nebraska and South Dakota samples
are in the personal collections of BJS.
We visited Valley
City State University in January 2023 to review their collections from
North Dakota. The specimens were from surveys conducted primarily for
the North Dakota Department of Health (NDDH) and the North Dakota
Department of Environmental Quality (NDEQ) using standard
semi-quantitative techniques, which included sieving bottom substrates.
They were collected between 1995 and 2020. The total number of records
from North Dakota is 178.
A map (in PDF format)
showing the distribution of all 795 of our unique sample sites is
available as Figure
1. No “absence stations” are
shown. If
freshwater gastropods were not collected at a site, then no record
resulted. Our entire 1,474 record database is available (as
an
excel spreadsheet) from the authors upon request.
The taxonomy employed by the FWGNA project is painstakingly researched, well-reasoned and insightful. Needless to say, it often differs strikingly from the gastropod taxonomy in common currency among casual users and most natural resource agencies. First-time visitors looking for information about particular species or genera might profitably begin their searches with a check for synonyms in our alphabetical index.
> Results
The 33 species of freshwater gastropods we have
confirmed from our four-state study area are listed in Table
1, both in
[pdf]
format and as a simple, sortable [excel]
spreadsheet. They are figured in the FWGGP gallery and
distinguished on the FWGGP dichotomous key. Ecological and
systematic notes for each species are provided on dedicated pages,
together with regional distribution maps.
> Discussion
See our separate Discussion page for a comparison of the freshwater gastropod fauna documented here to expectation from the historical literature, with an analysis of the biogeographic trends demonstrated across our four-state study area and recommendations for further study.
> Acknowledgements
Thanks to Kirsten Jensen, Mike Fritz & Steve Schainost, and Andre DeLorme for the invaluable help scouring agency and museum collections of Kansas, Nebraska, and North Dakota, respectively. We also thank the many colleagues who provided personal collections and museum samples, especially our good friend Dr. Will K. Reeves, whose relentless field efforts filled in many gaps.
> References
Anderson, T.K. 2004.
A review of the United States distribution of Melanoides tuberculatus
(Müller, 1774), an exotic freshwater snail. Ellipsaria, 6: 15-18.
Angelo, R., Cringan, M.
& Fry, J. 2002.
Distributional revisions and new and amended occurrence records for
prosobranch snails in Kansas. Trans. Kansas Acad. Sci. 105: 246 - 257.
Aughey, S. 1877.
Catalogue of the land and fresh-water shells of Nebraska. Bulletin of
the U.S. Geological and Geographical Survey of the Territories. (Hayden
Survey): 697-704.
Baker, FC. 1909.
Mollusks from Kansas and Oklahoma. Nautilus 23(7): 91-94.
Basch, P.F., Bainer, P.,
and Wilhm, J. 1961.
Some ecological characteristics of the Molluscan fauna of a typical
grassland situation in East central Kansas. American Midland Naturalist
66: 178–199.
Berg, D.J. 2011.
Railroads, United States, in Encyclopedia of the Great Plains. Wishart
D.J.(ed). Accessed 11 August 2023.
http://plainshumanities.unl.edu/encyclopedia/doc/ egp.tra.028.
Branson, B.A. 1963.
Additions to and distributional annotations on the Kansas gastropod
fauna. Transactions of the Kansas Academy of Science 66: 72-75.
Branson, B.A. 1969.
Distributional records and annotations for some Arkansas, Missouri and
Kansas Mollusks. Transactions of the Kansas Academy of Science 72:
386–393.
Bryce, S.A., Omernik,
J.M., Pater, D.A., Ulmer, M., Schaar, J., Freeouf, J., Johnson, R.,
Kuck, P., and Azevedo, S.H., 1996.
Ecoregions of North Dakota and South Dakota, (color poster with map,
descriptive text, summary tables, and photographs): Reston, Virginia,
U.S. Geological Survey (map scale 1:1,500,000).
Call, R.E. 1885a.
Contributions to the knowledge of the fresh-water Mollusca of Kansas
II: Fresh-water univalves. Bulletin of the Washburn College Laboratory
of Natural History 2(8):51-54.
Call, R.E. 1885b.
Contributions to a knowledge of the fresh-water Mollusca of Kansas. IV.
Washburn College Lab. Nat. Hist. Bull. 1(4): 115–124.
Call, R.E. 1886.
Fifth contribution to a knowledge of the fresh-water Mollusca of
Kansas. Washburn College Lab. Nat. Hist. Bull. 1(6): 177–184.
Call, R.E. 1887.
Sixth contribution to a knowledge of the fresh-water Mollusca of
Kansas. Washburn College Lab. Nat. Hist. Bull. 2(8): 11–25.
Chapman,
S.S., Omernik, J.M., Freeouf, J.A., Huggins, D.G., McCauley, J.R.,
Freeman, C.C., Steinauer, G., Angelo, R.T., and Schlepp, R.L., 2001.
Ecoregions of Nebraska and Kansas (color poster with map, descriptive
text, summary tables, and photographs): Reston, Virginia, U.S.
Geological Survey (map scale 1:1,950,000).
Clench, W.J. 1935.
Physa ampullacea
‘Gould’ Binney. The Nautilus 49: 30–32.
Cvancara, A.M. 1976.
Aquatic mollusks in North Dakota during the last 12000 years. Canadian
Journal of Zoology 54(10): 1688–1693.
Cvancara, A.M. 1983.
Aquatic Mollusks of North Dakota. Report of Investigation, no. 78.
North Dakota Geological Survey. 141.
Dahl, T.E. 2014.
Status and trends of prairie wetlands in the United States 1997 to
2009. U.S. Department of the Interior; Fish and Wildlife Service,
Ecological Services, Washington, D.C.
Franzen, D.S. and
Leonard, B. 1942. A Preliminary Survey of the Mollusca of
Kingman County, Kansas. Transactions of the Kansas Academy of Science
45: 334–343.
Franzen, D.S. 1944.
New state records of Mollusca from Kansas. Transactions of the Kansas
Academy of Science 47: 261-273.
Freeman, P.W. and
Perkins, K. 1992. Survey of Mollusks of the Platte River:
Final Report. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. Grand Is- land, Nebraska.
Freeman, P.W. and
Perkins, K. 1997. Survey of Mollusks of the Niobrara
River: Final Report. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. Grand Island,
Nebraska
Gugler, C. 1969.
Notes on Valvata tricarinata from Central Nebraska. American
Malacological Union Inc. Annual Report 36: 61–62.
Hanna, G.D. 1909.
Mollusca of Douglas County, Kansas. Nautilus 23(6-7): 81–82, 94–96.
Hayden, F.V. 1862.
On the geology and natural history of the upper Missouri. Transactions
of the American Philosophical Society 12(1): 1–218.
Hayden, F.V. 1868.
Final report of the United States geological survey of Nebraska and
portions of the adjacent territories, made under the direction of the
Commissioner of the General Land Office. By F. V. Hayden, United States
geologist. Professor Hayden's geological survey of Nebraska and
portions of adjacent Territories. Washington: Government Printing
Office.
Hayden, F.V. 1873.
Sixth Annual Report of the United States Geological Survey of the
Territories, Embracing Portions of Montana, Idaho, Wyoming, and Utah;
Being a Report of Progress of the Explorations for the Year 1872.
Washington: Government Printing Office.
Henderson, J. 1927.
Some South Dakota Mollusca. Nautilus 41(1): 19-20.
Hudson, J.C. 2011.
Agriculture, in Encyclopedia of the Great Plains. Wishart D.J.(ed).
Accessed 11 August 2023.
http://plainshumanities.unl.edu/encyclopedia/doc/egp.ag.001
Leonard, B. 1959.
Handbook of Gastropods in Kansas. Misc. Publ., no. 20.
Lawrence: Univ. Kansas Mus. Natl. Hist.
Over, W.H. 1915a.
Mollusca of South Dakota. Nautilus 29(7): 79-81.
Over, W.H. 1915b.
Mollusca of South Dakota (continued). Nautilus 29(8): 90-95
Over, W.H. 1928.
Additional records of South Dakota Mollusca. Nautilus 41(3): 92-93.
Stephen, B.J. 2015.
Species composition of Nebraska’s freshwater gastropod fauna: A review
of historical records. American Malacological Bulletin 33(1): 1-11.
Stephen, B.J. 2017. Distribution
and Conservation Status of the freshwater gastropods of Nebraska.
Transactions of the Nebraska Academy of Sciences and Affiliated
Societies 510. 32–39.
Stephen, B.J. 2018.
Distribution and conservation status of the freshwater gastropods of
South Dakota: A review of historical records and recent sampling.
BioRxiv (Pre-print).
Tuthill, S.J. and Laird,
W.M. 1963. Molluscan fauna of some alkaline lakes and
sloughs in southern central North Dakota. Nautilus 77(2): 47–55.
Tryon, G.W. 1868.
Notes on Mollusca collected by Dr. FV Hayden in Nebraska. American
Journal of Conchology 4(3): 150-51.
US-EPA Commission for
Environmental Cooperation 1997. Ecological Regions of
North America. Toward a Common Perspective.
Washington, DC. 71 pp.
US Geological
Survey. 1996.
National water summary on wetland resources. Compiled by Fretwell J.D.,
J.S. Williams, and P.J. Redman. USGS Water Supply Paper: 2425. 431 pp.
Wishart, David J. 2011.
The Great Plains Region, In: Encyclopedia of the Great Plains, Lincoln:
University of Nebraska Press. Accessed 11 August 2023.
http://plainshumanities.unl.edu/encyclopedia/intro.html
Wishart, D.J. 2013.
The last days of the rainbelt. University of Nebraska Press. 224 pp.
Walker, B. 1906.
A list of shells from Nebraska. Nautilus 20(7): 81-83.
Wayne, W.J. 1985.
Drainage patterns and glaciations in eastern Nebraska. Institute for
Tertiary-Quaternary Studies -TER-QUA Symposium Series 1: 111–117.